Will a rooftop cargo carrier hurt my gas mileage?

Yes, any rooftop storage will decrease fuel efficiency due to increased aerodynamic drag. Hard-shell cargo boxes, especially those with sleek, tapered designs, have the least impact. Cargo bags and open baskets will have a more significant effect. To minimize the impact, choose the most aerodynamic shape for your needs and remove the carrier when not in use.

Can I use a car roof storage box without a roof rack?

Generally, no. Hard-shell boxes and cargo baskets require a roof rack system with crossbars for secure mounting. However, many soft-sided cargo bags are specifically designed to be used on vehicles without a rack. They use straps that pass through the inside of the car and cinch down tightly.

Are car roof cargo carriers noisy?

They can be, but manufacturers have made significant improvements. Aerodynamic hard-shell boxes from brands like Thule and Yakima are engineered to be very quiet. Cargo baskets often come with a front fairing to deflect wind and reduce noise. Soft bags are quietest when packed full, as loose fabric can flap in the wind.

The Definitive Guide to the Best Car Roof Storage for 2025

Whether you’re planning an epic cross-country road trip, heading to the mountains with skis, or just need to reclaim your car’s interior from the chaos of family life, car roof storage is a game-changer. But the market is flooded with options: rigid cargo boxes, flexible bags, and rugged baskets. Choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. As an automotive gear expert who has tested countless setups, I’m here to demystify the process and guide you to the perfect solution for your vehicle and your adventures.

First, Do You Need a Box, a Bag, or a Basket?

This is the fundamental question. Your choice will impact security, weather resistance, and storage flexibility. Let’s break down the pros and cons of each.

Feature	Hard-Shell Cargo Box	Soft-Sided Cargo Bag	Open Cargo Basket
Best For	All-weather security, long-distance travel, carrying skis/snowboards.	Occasional use, bulky/oddly-shaped gear, budget-conscious buyers.	Overlanding, carrying rugged/oversized gear (coolers, spare tires).
Security	Excellent (Hard shell, integrated locks)	Low (Fabric, often requires separate padlock)	Low (Open design, relies on nets/straps)
Weather Resistance	Excellent (Fully waterproof and weatherproof)	Good to Very Good (Weather-resistant, not always 100% waterproof)	Poor (Gear is exposed to elements)
Aerodynamics	Best (Designed to reduce drag and wind noise)	Fair (Can be noisy if not fully packed)	Poor (Creates significant wind resistance)
Storage When Not in Use	Difficult (Large, bulky, requires garage/wall space)	Excellent (Folds down into a small bag)	Fair (Relatively flat, but still large)
Price	High	Low	Medium

Expert Advice on Making the Right Choice

In my experience, new families and casual travelers get the most value from a high-quality soft-sided bag. They are affordable, versatile, and easy to store. However, if you are a serious skier, a frequent road-tripper, or carry valuable gear, investing in a hard-shell cargo box is absolutely worth it for the security, weather protection, and peace of mind.

Key Factors to Consider Before You Buy

Beyond the type, you need to match the storage to your specific vehicle and needs. Don’t overlook these details.

Vehicle Compatibility & Roof Rack System: Does your car have factory-installed side rails, raised rails, or a bare roof? Most roof storage requires crossbars. Ensure the mounting hardware of your chosen carrier is compatible with your crossbar shape (square, round, aero/elliptical).
Capacity (Cubic Feet vs. Dimensions): Don’t just look at the cubic feet (liters). Check the interior length, width, and height. If you need to carry skis, you’ll need a long, narrow box. If you’re hauling bulky camping gear, a shorter, taller box might be better.
Hatch Clearance: This is a critical, often-forgotten measurement. Ensure the rear of the cargo box won’t interfere with your trunk or hatchback when it’s fully open. Most manufacturers provide a “hatch clearance” measurement.
Weight Limits: Your vehicle’s roof, your rack system, and the cargo carrier itself all have maximum weight limits. You must know all three and never exceed the lowest one. Remember to add the weight of the carrier itself to your cargo weight.

Top-Rated Car Roof Storage of 2025: Expert Picks

After extensive research and testing, here are my top recommendations available on Amazon, covering every category and budget.

Thule Motion XT XL, a sleek black aerodynamic rooftop cargo box.

Thule Motion XT XL – Best Overall

The Thule Motion XT is the gold standard. Its SlideLock system with separate locking and opening functions is brilliant, and the PowerClick mounting system is incredibly fast and secure. It offers fantastic aerodynamics, dual-side opening for easy access, and a generous 18 cubic feet of space. It’s the best all-rounder for serious travelers.

Check Price on Amazon

Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite, a textured black rooftop cargo box.

Yakima SkyBox 16 Carbonite – Best Value

Yakima delivers premium features without the absolute premium price. The SkyBox 16 offers 16 cubic feet of storage, a stiff, easy-to-open lid, and tool-free installation. The carbonite texture hides scuffs and scratches better than glossy finishes, making it a durable workhorse. An outstanding value for families and adventurers.

Check Price on Amazon

A black Fivklemnz rooftop cargo bag shown packed on a car roof.

Fivklemnz 21 Cubic ft Waterproof Bag – Best Cargo Bag

This bag is a fan favorite for a reason. Made from 600D heavy-duty PVC fabric with welded seams and a waterproof zipper flap, it offers genuine protection from the elements. It provides a massive 21 cubic feet of storage and can be used on cars with or without a roof rack, making it incredibly versatile. It includes an anti-slip mat for added security.

Check Price on Amazon

A black steel Yakima OffGrid cargo basket with a fairing.

Yakima OffGrid Cargo Basket – Best Basket

For those who need to haul bulky, rugged gear, the OffGrid is king. Its heavy-duty steel construction is bombproof. The tool-free mounting hardware is fully adjustable and fits most crossbars. The included fairing helps reduce wind noise. It’s perfect for coolers, firewood, or a spare tire, freeing up your interior for cleaner cargo.

Check Price on Amazon

About the Author: Alex Carter

Alex Carter is a mechanical engineer and seasoned automotive journalist with over 15 years of experience. He specializes in vehicle modifications and overland gear, having driven and customized vehicles on four continents. His rigorous, hands-on testing provides readers with practical, unbiased advice to help them get the most out of their adventures.

Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links to Amazon. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we have personally vetted and believe represent the best options for our readers.